Trust Your Sleep To Lancaster's Favorite Mattress Store
Locally Owned, Family Operated.
Gardner's Mattress & More has been voted Lancaster's Favorite Mattress Store by LNP Readers every year since 2010. Every day at Gardner's, we work hard to make sure every one of our customers has the same experience and outcome that reflects the high honor and trust our community places in us.
Google Reviews Facebook Reviews
Wake Up Happy Guaranteed
The Gardner’s Wake Up Happy Comfort Guarantee: Offered on any mattress purchased that is not a floor model or otherwise ineligible purchase. Try your new mattress for 120 nights, if after 60 nights you feel it is not the right mattress for you we will happily offer one (1) exchange at no charge or expense to you.
Learn More
The Gardner's Difference
We don't measure success by the mattresses we sell. We measure it by the lives we help sleep better.
Most people don't look forward to shopping for a mattress. They expect high-pressure salespeople. Confusing choices. Endless promotions. And a purchase they'll have to live with for the next 10 to 15 years.
We think there's a better way. At Gardner's Mattress & More, our mission has always been simple: Change the way people buy sleep.
Because we're not just helping you choose a mattress. We're helping you wake up healthier, recover better, and live a better life—one night at a time.
Built on Family. Driven by Service.
Gardner's has proudly served Lancaster County as a locally owned, family-operated business since 1990.
In 2011, Ben McClure and Jeff Giagnocavo purchased the business from founder Jim Gardner with a clear vision: not to become the biggest mattress store, but to become the most trusted.
Since then, we've introduced some of the world's most innovative sleep brands, advanced comfort technologies, adjustable sleep systems, and personalized sleep solutions, all designed around one goal: delivering a five-star experience every single time.
Why We Do Things Differently
We believe buying a mattress shouldn't feel like taking a gamble. You deserve the opportunity to experience the world's best sleep brands in person.
- You deserve honest guidance instead of pressure.
- You deserve transparent pricing.
- You deserve comfortable financing.
- You deserve service that continues long after delivery.
Most of all, you deserve to love where you spend one-third of your life.
That's why every recommendation answers your most pressing question: “What's the best solution for me?”
Our process matches our curated sleep solutions with your needs, not what's easiest to sell or rewards us the most.
Local Matters
As fellow small business owners, we believe local businesses strengthen local communities.
When you invest with Gardner's, you're supporting a family-owned company that's invested in the same schools, neighborhoods, charities, and businesses that make Lancaster County such a special place to call home.
The best part? Shopping local doesn't mean paying more.
We proudly offer the same competitive pricing you'd expect online, paired with expert guidance, personalized service, flexible financing, professional delivery, and support long after your purchase.
You get everything the internet offers, plus everything it can't.
More Than Awards. More Than Reviews.
We're incredibly grateful to have earned Lancaster County's trust, including being voted LNP Reader's Choice year after year and receiving hundreds of five-star reviews from customers throughout our community.
But the recognition we're proudest of isn't hanging on our wall.
It's when a customer tells us, “I wish I had done this years ago.”
Because at the end of the day, we're not here to sell mattresses. We're here to help people sleep better, live healthier, and wake up ready for whatever tomorrow brings.
That's the Gardner's difference. And we'd be honored to help you discover it for yourself.
Meet Lancaster's Favorite Mattress Team
Our team makes all the difference! We’re a team of passionate sleep specialist dedicated to helping you find the rest you deserve through personalized service and support.